The plot of “Goodbye, Michael” is relatively simple. As Michael prepares to head off to Colorado to live with his true love Holly, he very uncharacteristically plans to leave in secret: he tells the entire office he has one more day at work, when in fact he’ll be leaving on a plane that night. This leads to several great scenes where he makes a point of having a moment with or giving a gift to each of his co-workers individually, who don’t know it will be a final goodbye.
Michael Scott’s gifts, true to form, aren’t all well received. He gives Kevin the “gift” of ripping up a caricature of him as a dog-man salivating over pizza, and tells him to “never settle for who you are.” He gives Ryan his obnoxiously bright St. Pauli Girl sign, a fun reference to the Season 4 episode “Dinner Party,” and to save time says goodbye to Gabe, Creed, and Meredith all at once. He also successfully pulls off a prank, which is another Michael Scott rarity: telling Oscar, “You’re like my scarecrow, because you gave me a brain,” he gives him a truly terrifying homemade scarecrow doll, which Oscar dutifully, politely accepts.
In reality, Steve Carell was a little bit better of a gift-giver after wrapping his final episode: He gave each one of his co-stars a Rolex watch to remember him by. Kate Flannery (Meredith) told Uproxx, “I still wear it. It reminds me of that amazing experience.”